⚠ Preview mode — this review is not published yet.Close
Tasting review
Penelope Rosé Cask Finish
Penelope Bottling Company (MGP)
47% ABVBourbonReviewed 14 June 2026
82
01 — Appearance
ColorAmber
Viscosity / LegsMedium, medium legs
ImpressionAs always, Penelope is out here making some of the most beautiful bottles in the whiskey industry. For the Rosé cask, they skipped the paper and printed the label directly onto the glass. It's aggressively classy.
02 — Nose
IntensityMedium
First ImpressionThere is a lot going on here. It's basically a busy intersection of strawberry and vanilla.
DevelopmentIt opens up even more. The strawberry is still desperately trying to steal the spotlight, but it now has to share the stage with a very distinct Rosé wine cask influence.
Aroma Notes
VanillaStrawberryCinnamonBrown sugarToasted oak
03 — Palate
MouthfeelNice and viscous; it coats the mouth well.
ArrivalLands right on the mid-tongue, bringing a bit of astringency and a spicy little kick to wake you up.
Mid-palateThe strawberry and wine cask step up to become the dominant forces, bringing a decidedly "drying" sensation. That’s definitely the Rosé cask and oak tag-teaming your tastebuds.
BalanceLet's be honest, it’s not a very "balanced" bourbon, but it completely owns what it is: an unapologetic Rosé cask finish.It might not be a masterclass in complexity, but it undeniably has personality.
Flavor Notes
StrawberryRosé wineDried cherryoak
04 — Finish
Finish LengthShort
CharacterOaky and dry. Think of it as the bourbon equivalent of a dry humor punchline.
Not much sticking around besides that oaky dryness.
Lingering
Oak tanninsLingering sweetnessCocoa
It is a genuinely fun, finished bourbon that I personally enjoy, but I can already hear the purists running for the hills because that Rosé finish is quite prominent. Still, it makes for a highly unique entry to log in the Whiskey Vault.Beginner Friendly? Only if they already like Rosé wine.
Daily Sipper? No. Your palate needs a break.
Complex Dram? No, it knows exactly what its gimmick is.
Value for Money? If you can grab it at MSRP ($60), yes!
Would I buy it again? Yes.
— Mattias Schill, WhiskeyVault
Score
82/100
This is a bourbon that forces you to pick a side—there is absolutely no middle ground here.