⚠ Preview mode — this review is not published yet. Close
Tasting review

Penelope Four Grain, Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Bottled by Penelope Bourbon Bottling Company

40% ABVBourbonReviewed 14 June 2026
Penelope Four Grain, Straight Bourbon Whiskey 75
ColorYellow Gold
Viscosity / LegsLight and short legs
ImpressionPenelope simply never misses when it comes to bottle design. It's classy, elegant, and actually gives you the information you want to read. The crisp white label with gold embossed letters looks fantastic on the bar cart.
IntensityLow
First ImpressionA buttery sweetness heavily leaning on maple syrup, with just a polite little tap of orange peel.
DevelopmentTwenty minutes later... it’s exactly the same. It’s not shy, and it’s certainly not evolving. It’s just fiercely committed to its own personality.
Aroma Notes
SweetButtery mapleAppleCitrus peel
MouthfeelLight and creamy
ArrivalConfidently lands right on the sides of the tongue, dropping off a quick delivery of cinnamon and sweetness.
Mid-palateHello, dusty peanut shells! They show up alongside some sweetness, but we're talking basic "table sugar" sweet rather than anything overly complex.
BalanceA very simple, straight-down-the-middle beginner bourbon.
Flavor Notes
Peanut shellsMaple syrup
Finish LengthShort
CharacterYou get your classic bourbon notes of vanilla and caramel, but it's like someone explicitly told them to use their indoor voices. Then, a slightly bitter note sneaks in at the very end like an uninvited party guest.
Lingering
Vanilla
Think of it as the ultimate gateway bourbon for absolute beginners, or for that one friend who genuinely believes "high proof" is a personality flaw. The Recommendation: Great for beginners Great if you want something incredibly easy Great if you are actively terrified of ABV
— Mattias Schill, WhiskeyVault